In New York state, breweries cannot sell beer directly to bars. Breweries are required to sell their beer to a distribution company that then sells the beer to bars. A brewery’s fate is largely in the hands of their distributor. Currently, if a brewery isn’t well represented by their distributor, it is often almost impossible for the brewery to switch distributors. A new bill up for vote in the New York State Senate is offering small breweries the ability to end their relationship with a distributor if they fairly compensate the distributor to exit the agreement. The bill would give small breweries the ability to choose the best distributor for their beer and still make sure that distributors are fairly compensated.
What would this bill do for you, the craft beer lover? Small breweries could avoid getting stuck in contracts where their beer is lost in the shuffle and would be free to get the best representation. It would likely help more small breweries make it, increasing the diversity and availability of great beers in the market.
Scott Vaccaro, of Captain Lawrence Brewery in Westchester, NY, recently wrote an email urging beer lovers to support the legislation:
Dear Beer Activists,
Please read the information below, provided by the New York State Brewers Association, concerning an important piece of legislation which, if passed, would help ensure greater access and choice for consumers of craft beer in the Empire State.
New York Craft Brewers need your help!
We are asking for your support of the NY Craft Brewers’ efforts to pass an important amendment to the laws governing beer distribution in New York.
Under current law, it is very difficult, expensive and sometimes practically impossible for small brewers to switch from one wholesale distributor of their beer to another. The laws now in effect were enacted about 15 years ago to protect beer wholesalers from unfair distribution contract termination by large, multinational breweries. Wholesalers were legitimately concerned because all too often when a brewery moved its brands, the former wholesaler went totally uncompensated for all the time and effort spent in building sales of those brands.
In 2008, however, the beer and brewing landscape is very different. Although there are fewer wholesalers, those remaining are much larger companies and while multinational breweries certainly exist, the rise and proliferation of small, local craft breweries means that many brewers are smaller than the wholesalers they do business with.
Yet, these small craft brewers are required to operate under the same “franchise” laws that were created to protect the wholesalers from large brewers. Unfortunately, today these same franchise laws are being used by wholesalers to lock in the distribution rights and restrict access to market for these small brewers. Clearly, this is not good for small brewers, but it’s also very bad for consumers because it means less choice in terms of fewer brands and fewer breweries available on store shelves.
S 6101 proposes a change to that law so that any small brewer that is less than 5% of a wholesaler’s business will have the ability to terminate a relationship with a wholesaler providing they pay fair compensation to that wholesaler, i.e. what the brand has transferred for with other wholesalers over the past 12 months or a minimum of 2 times gross profit. Thus, S 6101 relieves small brewers from the franchise laws but importantly would continue to compensate the wholesaler for value of the brand rights if they are terminated.
On behalf of the New York State Brewers Association, please call or email your New York State Senator at his or her Albany office as soon as possible and urge them to support S 6101. This bill has already passed the Assembly and could come up for a vote in the Senate at any time.
Senators’ contact information can be found at http://www.senate.state.ny.us/senatehomepage.nsf/senators?OpenForm
If you are unsure of who your Senator is, please visit: http://www.senate.state.ny.us/sdlookup.nsf/Public_search?OpenForm
KEY POINTS TO INCLUDE IN YOUR COMMUNICATION:
I am a craft beer drinker and it upsets me that some craft beers are being held hostage by the franchise laws.
The small craft brewers in New York State are not only making great beer, they are making a contribution to the state’s economy.
The franchise laws as they exist in NY today are a burden on this growing industry and a restraint on small brewers being able to develop their business.
I urge you to amend these laws and vote yes for S 6101.
Thank you for your support of New York’s craft brewers and consumers.
—-
Thank you for all your support in the past. Right now we could really use your help more than ever to secure the future of our brewery. If you have the time please contact your State Senator and voice your support for S 6101.
Thanks,
Scott Vaccaro
Captain Lawrence Brewing Co.
99 Castleton St
Pleasantville, NY 10570
914-741-2337
www.CaptainLawrenceBrewing.com